Lawless is a good movie. Is it great? I don’t know. There was something about it that couldn’t let me fully enjoy it. The person I went with loved it. They cried, like, four times during the movie. They proclaimed it was a great film. I couldn’t.
Just like in The Dark Knight Rises I think part of that was Tom Hardy’s voice. Everyone else in the movie spoke plain English with slight accents. They had Hardy talk in a bad southern accent with a mouth full of marbles. He primarily grunted a lot.
The film takes place in Virginia during the depression and prohibition. The Bondurant brothers kind of rule the roost in the moonshine business. Legend has it they are also invincible. There’s Howard, Jason Clarke (“Brotherhood,” Public Enemies, Death Race), the oldest. He fought during WWI and mainly just gets drunk a lot. He would be the enforcer of the family. Forrest, Tom Hardy (Inception, The Dark Knight Rises, Warrior), is the middle child. He’s also the leader. Then there’s the baby brother, Jack, Shia LaBeouf (Transformers, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, Disturbia). Jack has aspirations of becoming a big time gangster like his idol, Floyd Banner, Gary Oldman (The Fifth Element, Leon: The Professional, The Dark Knight). However, Jack isn’t built like his brothers. He doesn’t have the muscle or the grit to stand up for himself and/or be violent when necessary. The men have a nice life until Special Deputy Charlie Rakes, Guy Pearce (Memento, L.A. Confidential, The Hurt Locker), comes to town. The man from Chicago is determined to shut down the liquor business…or at least get a cut of their profit, but the Bondurant’s will have none of that. So, a feud begins. After an injury to Forrest, Jack makes a deal with Banner to up their production. This also increases their money. It also makes them gangster like kings of back country moonshine.
There are two love stories in this movie. Both aren’t really necessary. Jacks love interest is Bertha Minnix, Mia Wasikowska (Jane Eyre, Albert Nobbs, Alice in Wonderland), the daughter of a strict religious preacher. You can imagine how that goes. For the most part the gorgeous Wasikowska goes unused. The only noteworthy scene with her is when she puts on a yellow dress. You read that right. I have no other way of describing that scene. It’s a tender moment and she steals the entire scene. The other love interest is Jessica Chastain (The Help, Take Shelter, The Tree of Life) as Maggie Beauford. She’s Forrest’s love interest, she works at the Bondurant’s restaurant/diner/thingie, and she’s from the city. Chastain is also not used very well. They only require her to show any real emotion once in the film, and her nude scene was awkward and unnecessary. I can’t believe I just complained about that.
I already mentioned my disdain for Tom Hardy’s voice so lets move on to the other major players. LaBeouf was…LaBeouf? They’re still giving the 26 year old roles that seem fit for a teenager. Childlike innocence. Naive. I wonder what he could have done if he was given the role of Forrest. His performance wasn’t bad, but it’s not exactly memorable either. Guy Pearce was another one that annoyed the shit out of me. I love the little character traits he has. It’s interesting to see a badass gangster-like being with a germ problem. However, his lack of eyebrows and severe part in his hair left me puzzled. I think a normal Pearce can be intimidating enough without drastically and comically altering his appearance. The dark horse in this one is Dane DeHaan (Chronicle) who plays Cricket Pate. The best way to describe him would probably be a crippled genius. He’s the brains behind the mechanics of the operation, but it’s his childlike innocence that wins the character. Opposite of LaBeouf his innocence is endearing. His performance was fantastic.
So why was it good? Well…the music is awesome. The setting is gorgeous. In all seriousness I’m a huge fan of the gangster/mobster genre. I liked seeing one that took it out of the big city and brought it into a small focus. We’ve always seen the gangster movies where they’re bringing the liquor in, but we’ve never had the opportunity to see where that liquor came from. The violence is also done extremely well. More like A History of Violence than Scarface.
The movie is directed by John Hillcoat. His most notable work is with the Viggo Mortensen helmed The Road. The film is based on the novel “The Wettest County in the World” by Matt Bondurant, and the screenplay is done by notable composer Nick Cave. He’s worked on the soundtrack for films like Scream, Shrek 2, Hellboy, and The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford.
I would say to go see it in theatres for the cinematography alone, but you can really wait until this one is online or it comes out on DVD.